The day after: The press on ‘In Rainbows’

October 1st 2007 is the day Radiohead shocked not only their fans, but also the music industry and the press by offering their new album ‘In Rainbows’ as a download, without a label and with a unique pricing method.

TIME magazine writes: Few suspected the band members had the ambition (or the server capacity) to put an album out on their own. The final decision was apparently made just a few weeks ago, and, when informed of the news on Sunday, several record executives admitted that, despite the rumors, they were stunned. “This feels like yet another death knell,” emailed an A&R executive at a major European label. “If the best band in the world doesn’t want a part of us, I’m not sure what’s left for this business.”

A producer who works primarily with American rap artists says: “Radiohead is the best band in the world; if you can pay whatever you want for music by the best band in the world, why would you pay $13 dollars or $.99 cents for music by somebody less talented? Once you open that door and start giving music away legally, I’m not sure there’s any going back.”

The Times: “Radiohead have done something remarkably radical. This isn’t the way the music industry – or, indeed, any industry, has ever worked. [...] What this move really relies on though, is the notion that between Radiohead and their fans is a collateral of trust and, dare the term be uttered, decency. Whilst that collateral might not be there between, say Sugababes and their fans, it’s the very thing that has propelled Radiohead to this point of unprecedented autonomy. If this experiment works, it will – at the click of a few million mice – make them the most powerful band in Britain.”

Globe And Mail: “Will Radiohead’s experiment lead others to try the “pay what you want” model? That’s difficult to say. As some have pointed out — including Cynthia Brumfield at IPDemocracy — Radiohead has a fan base that is likely willing to pay handsomely for its music, the same way that fans of Pearl Jam are willing to pay extra for high-quality downloads of the band’s music after live shows. Not every group is going to be able to make that work.”

According to Meriel Blackburn, The Official Chart Company‘s Head Of Chart Operations, the uniqueness of the album’s availability has put its chart eligibility in doubt. She told NME.COM: “As they are not a chart reporting retailer (any retailer which supplies their sales data to the chart panel), we don’t currently receive sales information from them for inclusion in the charts. On chart eligibility, we have chart rules that products have to meet for us to include their sales in the UK charts. These cover content and packaging, etc. In this case we don’t know enough about the products to be able to say whether they would meet the chart rules and be eligible.” If Radiohead‘s last few album releases are anything to go by, it is almost certain the record would top the album charts if it was eligible. A final ruling on whether the record will chart is expected soon.

And some quotes, published in LA Times: “This is all anybody is talking about in the music industry today,” said Bertis Downs, the longtime manager of R.E.M., the veteran alt-rock band that was inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame this year. “This is the sort of model that people have been talking about doing, but this is the first time an act of this stature has stepped up and done it. . . . They were a band that could go off the grid, and they did it.”

Another high-profile manager said he was still trying to process the boldness of the Radiohead venture. “My head is spinning, honestly,” said Kelly Curtis, who represents Seattle-based Pearl Jam. “It’s very cool and very inspiring, really.”

“Only a band in Radiohead’s position could pull a trick like this,” is how Pitchforkmedia.com summed it up Monday. That’s because the band became a free agent after its contract with music giant EMI expired with its most recent album, “Hail to the Thief” in 2003. That set the stage for a one-band revolution, even if the five members don’t see it that way themselves.

“It’s more of an experiment. The band is not fighting for the sake of the fight or trying to lead a revolution,” said their spokesman, Steve Martin of New York publicity firm Nasty Little Man. The group declined to comment Monday.


Radiohead news on this day..


1700 days ago by in Radiohead News | You can follow any responses to this entry through the RSS feed. You can leave a response, or trackback from your own site.
  • http://www.martop.net Carlos

    IMHO, this is a movement that others wanted to do but only Radiohead had the guts to. And I’m happy about this way. There’s nothing industry can do against internet.

  • Matt

    Anyone read this from Radiohead’s PR company to journalists, reviewers, etc:

    “There will be no advances, promotional copies, digital streams, media sites, etc. of RADIOHEAD’s In Rainbows.

    Everyone in the world will be getting the music at the same time: Oct. 10. That includes us. We don’t have anything to play anyone in the nine days until the record is available. Everyone at nasty has put his or her order in and just to clarify: you are not being asked to pay for a promo (as some have inquired). you can pay nothing or as much or as little as you want.

    There will be no promotional copies of the discbox either, as each discbox is being made to order. Sorry.”

  • Matt

    Cool.

  • zaydon

    Radiohead.com or whatever site hosts this is so gonna crash at 00:00 GMT. If anyone has half a brain they’ll make this into a torrent. Can you imagine 2,000,000 peers and 30,000,000 leeches. :-)

  • Matt

    Although I’ve never been a huge Radiohead fan I must say a few things. The band did an amazing job at keeping this under wraps and making sure it doesn’t leak out. They also did a great job with publicity; it was discreet, but once word got out there was no way to stop it spreading

    I hope other bands will learn an example from these guys.

  • Lel

    RADIOHEAD YOU ONLY STICK WITH ME BECAUSE THERE ARE NO OTHERS… ♥

  • Cacophonaut

    I think zaydon has a point, no way is inraibows.com able to handle that kind of data interchange.
    Midnight next tuesday, say goodbye to the site, and probably dead air space as well since they are probably on the same server.
    Ill try anyway just to see what happens

  • http://radiohode.org radiohode

    I bought the box, and wouldn’t hestitated even if the price was £ 400. I’ve waited more than four years…

  • Yorkie

    Seems a conicidence that Prince releases his album for free – okay you had to buy a
    newspaper – and now this.
    The band wasn’t sure about their decision right up till the last minute so maybe this isn’t the way forward, but merely an act of rebellion?
    Most rebels are finally defeated so maybe this is a historical one off.
    We shall see.

  • SeanG

    Well if they’re smart about it, they’ll have a private torrent going.

  • http://www.maestrosync.com maestro

    Or they might stagger the release starting from a day or two before the 10th.

  • Pingback: Hidden Track » Friday's Leftovers: Iran Into Trouble

  • http://unique.moldfish.com/workonline.rss/ SOPHIE

    Shiver my timbers

  • http://users3.nofeehost.com/infose/fluval-media-foam.html HAYDEN

    Halcyon days

  • http://iformant.freehostia.com/viagra/viagra-side-effects.html CALVIN

    In the doldrums

  • http://users3.nofeehost.com/infose/pump.html PRINCESS

    Laugh like a drain

  • http://casinoplaydirect.info/viagra/effects-of-viagrra.html TEAGAN

    Take the cake

  • http://iformant.freehostia.com/personal-web-site.html MADISON

    A sea change

  • http://casinoplaydirect.info/viagra/viagrra-alternative.html PEPPER

    Blood and thunder

  • http://users3.nofeehost.com/infose/heater.html GUINNESS

    Rack your brains

  • http://users3.nofeehost.com/howtos/index2.html AMELIA

    Hissy fit

  • http://casinoplaydirect.info/viagra/viagrra-pill.html ELIJAH

    Flesh and blood

  • http://iformant.freehostia.com/internet-personal.html MURPHY

    Rhyming slang

  • http://iformant.freehostia.com/viagra/vigra-for-woman.html PETYON

    Everybody out

  • http://users3.nofeehost.com/infose/fish.html SAMSON

    Loaf of bread

  • Pingback: Radiohead’s ‘In Rainbows’ first anniversary | Radiohead At Ease [In Rainbows]

  • http://nutrisystemvsjennycraig.com Lauren Kenndy

    Pretty nice post. I just stumbled upon your weblog and wished to say that I have truly enjoyed browsing your blog posts. In any case I will be subscribing to your feed and I hope you write again very soon! eye stye treatment